Friday, April 23, 2010

0 Eating Caviar the Russian Way, Part 1

Pin It

The following few posts will be Russian recipes featuring caviar. Before I post the recipes, I thought it'd be a good idea to talk a little bit about caviar first -- starting with a basic definition, and then moving on its origins, classifications, sustainability concerns, processing methods, health properties, typical preparations, handling and serving techniques, shelf life, storage, selection, and related culinary terminology, etc. Since there's a lot of important information I'd like to share with you on these topics, I'll be breaking this article into two separate posts. :)

It is my hope that this background information will not only help to make you feel more at home in the kitchen when it comes to preparing the corresponding recipes, but will also provide useful insights to help you practice & enjoy the experience of responsible caviar consumption.

Origins & Classifications: Caviar is basically the processed, unfertilized fish eggs (or roe) of wild sturgeon. Sturgeon are one of the world's oldest vertebrate species on Earth, dating back to prehistoric times. Going back over 250 million years, they've even survived the dinosaurs! They can live a hundred years, grow to over 20 feet in length, and weigh more than 2,200 lbs.!

The four varieties of "true" caviar, (i.e., sturgeon roe), are BelugaOsetraSevruga, and Sterlet, (the last of which is very rare & no longer sold commercially). Each type of caviar is named after the species of sturgeon that produces them.

While there are many other types of fish roe commercially marketed as "caviar," only the fish roe of sturgeon may technically be called "caviar," regardless of its origins -- i.e., the United States, Russia, Iran, or anywhere else. When the word "caviar" is used on its own, it implies that the roe is from sturgeon. All other classifications of "caviar" are really caviar substitutes, and are typically referred to as "fish roe" or "fish roe caviar." In these instances, the word "caviar" will typically be preceded by another term (like "lumpfish" or "salmon," etc.) to indicate its true origins. When in doubt, read the fine print on the label. :)

Sustainability Although caviar connoisseurs consider sturgeon roe to be premium, "true" caviar, this thinking has been revised by many, particularly as sturgeon roe has now become extremely rare, due to dwindling populations caused by overfishing (almost to extinction!), rampant poaching, pollution, & interference with their natural habitat. :(

Really, there's no need to kill off an entire species (or more accurately put, any of the remaining species!) just for the sake of satisfying a few fleeting moments of culinary ecstasy. That is just sheer stupidity & short-sighted gluttony. Remember the parable about the goose that laid the golden eggs? Now just keep that image in your brain but instead replace the word "goose" with the word "fish." ;) 

Due to sustainability concerns, I'd recommend consuming other (i.e., read "non-endangered"!) types of caviar whenever possible. There are several decent (not to mention, far less exorbitantly priced!) kinds of caviar that come from other types of fish. For example, hackleback, Choupique (a.k.a. bowfin), lumpfish, American Golden (a.k.a. whitefish roe), salmon, trout, avruga (a.k.a. herring roe), and American caviar (from American lake sturgeon) are just a small list of some of the currently available alternatives. (Paddlefish caviar is often cited as an "alternative" caviar, but since it's now been added to the list of "vulnerable" species, it's probably best to either limit or altogether cease your consumption of this variety or better yet, switch to a sustainable variety instead.)

There are several compelling reasons to make the switch to sustainable caviar: For one, sturgeon roe is rare precisely because sturgeons are on the verge of extinction. At present, there are only 27 species of sturgeon left, all of which are on the endangered species list (!), and of that subset, 4 species haven't been spotted in quite some time and so, not surprisingly, are currently listed as "possibly extinct." Just how dire is this situation? In March 2010, the IUCN reported that over 85% of all remaining sturgeon species are now classified as "endangered or critically endangered," (i.e., they are at serious risk for extinction), making them the most critically endangered group of species of all.  Of course, as species of plants & animals start disappearing from our planet, this creates an imbalance in the food chain that can really wreak havoc with the ecosystem. This chain-reaction affects every living species on the planet, including humans! Of course, we can reverse these trends via global conservation efforts & responsible consumption practices.

Of the three remaining types of commercially sold, "true" caviar, Beluga is the generally considered to be the best. However, due to its high demand over the years, overfishing has put undue strain upon the species, also making it one of the rarest, and thus, most expensive types of caviar. Also compounding the issue is Beluga's slow maturation cycle: In order to produce eggs, the Beluga must first reach adulthood, which takes at least 20 years! In an effort to protect this endangered species, the United States Fish and Wildlife Service, as of 2005, has banned the import of Beluga caviar from the Caspian Sea as well as the entire Black Sea basin. At present, it is illegal to import Beluga caviar into the US and also to transport any existing Beluga caviar currently located in the US across state lines.

Another smart, albeit admittedly less noble, reason to switch is this: Your wallet. :) Or rather, what'll be left of it after you pay a king's ransom for a microscopically small tin of overpriced fish eggs. ;) Of course, the rarer the caviar, the more expensive it is. Yet another compelling reason to switch, particularly in the current economy. :)

For example, let's consider the price tag of the rarest variety of caviar in the world, Golden Almas, a highly-prized, white Osetra caviar harvested from the endangered albino sturgeon, which make their home in the Caspian sea & are, on average 60-100+ years of age! (The older the sturgeon, the subtler & creamier the flavor of its roe. However, if people keep eating it, it won't be around to enjoy for much longer.)

In its most extravagant format, this particular brand of white Osetra caviar is packaged in a 24K gold tin which costs $25,000 USD per 35 oz., or $710 an ounce (!). At that astronomic price, it's even more expensive than gold itself, which is about $600 per ounce! That's a rather hefty price tag for most mere mortals. Quite fittingly, "almas" is the Persian word for "diamonds." ;)

(White Osetra caviar was once considered to be so luxurious that it was reserved only for tsars and shahs. This is why white Osetra caviar also often referred to as 'Imperial' or 'Royal' caviar. Strangely enough, it was also once eaten by Russian peasants well before it became such an exclusive commodity.)

And finally, here's yet another reason to make the switch to sustainable caviar: Your health. :) Consider this: Contaminated water has been a huge problem in the Caspian Sea, where a large majority of wild sturgeon live. Not only do these fish swim in polluted waters, but they eat food from those waters as well. And, due to the fact that all species of wild sturgeon have remain unchanged since their beginnings, their immune systems have not adapted to protect them against the pollutants of modern industry. Because they have not evolved and thus, cannot fight off the ravages of pollution, think of what that means for you if you were to eat wild sturgeon roe.

Now consider the advantages of eating sustainable farmed caviar: Unlike wild sturgeon, farmed sturgeon swim in clean artesian well water and are fed all-natural feed.

Also, equally important is the following factor: Farmed sturgeon are not killed in order to extract their caviar. Instead, the eggs are removed in a C-section like fashion, the wound is stitched up to keep the fish alive, and then the fish is then returned to the water. This way, the sturgeon population doesn't have to be endangered in the process, and the female fish population can continue to produce more roe during their lifetime. Contrast this to the historical practices of commercial wild sturgeon fishermen, who stun the fish by clubbing its head and extracting the ovaries. The wild sturgeon is basically clubbed to death in order to obtain their roe. Once the roe is extracted, that's one less female fish to continue the cycle of life for the wild sturgeon population.

As you can see, sound and humane ecological practices will help ensure the survival of future generations of sturgeon, and thus, allow us to continue to enjoy their roe as well. :)

Processing and Packaging Methods: Ever wonder how caviar is processed? Here's the basic method: The caviar maker, or ikrjanschik in Russian, takes a large sac of roe and runs it over a very fine mesh screen that separates the eggs into separate pieces. The eggs then fall into a large bowl, whereupon the caviar maker adds precise amounts of pure sea salt (and sometimes other ingredients as well). (Salt is added to prevent freezing. It's used both as a preservative and as a curing agent.) The caviar is then graded and packed into 4 pound tins. Importers will then repackage these tins into smaller amounts, which are typically around 1 oz. in size. Beluga caviar is always packaged in blue tins, Osetra in yellow, and Sevruga in red. Other types of fish roe are typically packaged in glass jars.

The above steps must be done swiftly and gingerly, both to maintain freshness and protect the fragile nature of the eggs. It's a painstaking process, which requires a lot of skill and many years of experience. This is why a minimum of 10-15 years of apprenticeship is required before an ikrjanschik is allowed to process caviar on his own.

There are four (4) different caviar processing methods:

Malossol: This way of processing caviar is considered to be the highest quality method of preserving caviar,  and is generally preferred by carviar connoisseurs. The term malossol means to "lightly salted" in Russian, although it's sometimes used to describe any caviar of high quality, primarily because only the highest quality eggs can be prepared and labelled in this way. This type of caviar has less than 5% salt content, although today's version often contains even less salt, around 3.5%. Only pure salt is used to process caviar in the US and Iran, although in Russia and some European countries (like France), a small amount of borax (!) is legally permitted to be used as an additive. Borax is thought to help preserve the caviar and is supposed to enhance its natural flavor by sweetening it slightly. There's only one problem with that concept; borax is a toxic substance. ;) There are some serious health hazards and risks associated with borax, and so not surprisingly it's been banned as a food additive in the US. The risks clearly outweigh the benefits, and so it's patently obvious that processing plants don't really have a worthwhile enough justification for using it. As many of you surely already know, borax is also commonly used as a bleaching agent and is often found in cleaning solutions. I don't know about you, but just the idea of adding it to food sounds a bit scary to me. If common sense and instinct aren't kicking into overdrive right about now, please promptly smack yourself into reality. ;) Do you want to play Russian Roulette with your health?! (Pun intended. ;) ) I know I don't. I'd rather not eat caviar from countries that use borax, thank you very much. (This reminds me of the way some companies "clean" various kinds of oil, which is an extremely unhealthy and toxic process, because these oils have been refined with harsh, corrosive chemical solvents that damage the oils' molecules, which, in turn, significantly damage cells in the body.) So, I'd recommend going with the salted variety, just to play it on the safe side. And since borax-treated caviar is illegal in many countries, including the US, that probably won't be too hard of a practice to adhere to for most of you. ;)

Salted: This method of processing is considered to be slightly less desirable in quality than Malassol, and is sometimes referred to as 'semi-preserved' caviar. It has a higher salt content, containing up to 8% salt. While the increased amount of salt is used to extend caviar's shelf life, it also negatively affects its flavor. This type of caviar is generally destined for the US marketplace, where borax is thankfully prohibited by law.

Pressed caviar: Pressed caviar, or payusnaya ikra in Russian, is the next rung down in terms of quality, although its shelf life is greater than the above two types. When kept in a refrigerated and unopened, sealed container, pressed caviar can keep for up to 8 months, that is, from the time it hits the store shelves. Typically made from too soft, immature, or overly ripe Sevruga or Osetra roe that's been damaged in processing, it's treated by placing it into highly salted, hot brine, shaken until its no longer milky, stored into small oak barrels coated with paraffin, and then pressed through cheesecloth into a soft, jam or paste-like consistency. (This removes any excess liquid.) Once the only available method used to preserve caviar, this type of caviar was once so thick that it could be sliced with a knife. (This is because it used to be dried and pressed more in the past.) Not surprisingly, pressed caviar has an extremely strong and concentrated flavor. (It takes 15 lbs. of roe to make a 2.2 lb. of pressed caviar!) In addition to being intensely salty, it's also exceedingly fishy tasting, and thus, is often considered to be an acquired taste. :) It's also very difficult to find outside of Russia. Of course, all of these factors probably play into the reasons behind its appeal to caviar connoisseurs. ;) Even though it's of lower quality than malassol or salted caviar, it's often recommended for cooking, and is still considered to be a favorite amongst many chefs and aficionados alike.

Pasteurized: This type of caviar is the lowest on the totem pole in terms of quality, texture, and taste, but has the longest shelf-life: From the time it hits the store shelves, pasteurized caviar can be kept for in a refrigerated and unopened, sealed container for up to a year, but needs to be consumed within a few days once opened. During the pasteurization process, the caviar is heat treated and then vacuum packed in glass jars. From there, it's then placed into hot water baths at a constant temperature of about 140°F. This process typically occurs with 3-4 hours after the fish has reached the processing plant, in order to prolong its shelf life as much as possible. There are those who claim that pasteurization, when carried out correctly, shouldn't change the flavor of the caviar, although the eggs will typically become a bit firmer.

As you can see, when it comes to caviar, there's generally a trade-off between taste and shelf-life. ;) Therein lies the paradox: Less salt means better flavor but faster spoilage and higher prices, while more salt means slower spoilage and comparatively lower prices but a lower caliber flavor. As you can see, the amount of salt added to caviar is often inversely proportion to its overall quality.

OK, that's probably enough information to absorb for one post. :) Part 2 will be posted next....

No comments:

Post a Comment

I may or may not know you, but love reading your comments!

Have you tried this recipe? If so, please leave a comment or post your reaction to let me know what you think.

If you like this post, then please consider subscribing to my RSS feed. You can also subscribe by email and have new posts sent directly to your inbox.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...